Zhōngwén
(Zhōng·wén
{Central → [Chinese]} · Writing
中文) ← Tap/click to show/hide the “flashcard”
As discussed in last week’s MEotW, the expression
“Zhōngguó
(Zhōng·guó
Central · Nation → [China]
中国
中國)”
is commonly used to refer to China, since historically, China views itself as the centre of the world, so much so, in fact, that it is the only nation to name itself as such. We can see then that Mandarin expressions starting with “Zhōng
(Central → [Chinese]
中)-”
can refer to things related to China.
In that case then, are “Zhōnghuà
(Zhōng·huà
{Central → [Chinese]} · Speech
中话
中話)” or “Zhōngyǔ
(Zhōng·yǔ
{Central → [Chinese]} · Language
中语
中語)” used to refer to any Chinese language, similarly to how “pǔtōnghuà
(pǔ·tōng·huà
common; universal · {through(out) → [common]} · speech → [(Modern Standard) Mandarin (term commonly used in China)]
普通话
普通話)” and “Guóyǔ
(Guó·yǔ
National · Language → [(Modern Standard) Mandarin (term commonly used in Taiwan)]
国语
國語)” are used to refer to Mandarin? Apparently not, according to my dictionaries.
Instead, Chinese people commonly use “Zhōngwén
(Zhōng·wén
{Central → [Chinese]} · Writing
中文)”—this week’s MEotW—to mean “Chinese language”. It should be noted, though, that although “Zhōngwén
(Zhōng·wén
{Central → [Chinese]} · Writing
中文)” is often used to refer to Chinese speech (e.g., in “shuō
(speak
说
說/説)
Zhōngwén
(Zhōng·wén
{Central → [Chinese]} · Writing
中文)” (“speak Chinese”)), “wén
(writing; script [→ [language | culture]]
文)” really means “writing”.
Why do so many Chinese people thus conflate writing with speech and language, when they, while related, are really distinctly different things? This seems to be a symptom of the deeply ingrained Chinese cultural conceit that the Chinese characters are the primary aspect of the Chinese languages—to many Chinese people, the characters are the language. This is contrary to the principle recognized by modern linguists (language scientists) that speech is the primary aspect of any language, not writing. The truth of this basic linguistic principle is shown by the fact that many languages don’t even have a writing system, showing that the required foundation of a language is its speech, not its writing.
Our Creator himself touches on this matter in his Word the Bible:
8 For if the trumpet sounds an indistinct call, who will get ready for battle? 9 In the same way, unless you with the tongue use speech that is easily understood, how will anyone know what is being said? You will, in fact, be speaking into the air. 10 It may be that there are many kinds of speech in the world, and yet no kind is without meaning. 11 For if I do not understand the sense of the speech, I will be a foreigner to the one speaking, and the one speaking will be a foreigner to me.—1 Corinthians 14:8–11.
Yes, Jehovah God himself, the One who designed us with our ability to use language, emphasizes the primary importance of understandable speech when it comes to communicating with people, especially when communicating about the potentially life-saving good news of the Kingdom.
Chinese people, however, often have the mistaken view, based on nothing more than deeply ingrained human tradition and not a little cultural pride, that their characters writing system is the primary aspect of the Chinese languages. So, we must take that into consideration when they or people deferring to them erroneously tell us, with all sincerity, that we need to focus first on Chinese characters in our efforts to learn one or more of the Chinese languages. The truth, as testified to by both real language experts among humans and by the Creator himself, is that speech—both understanding speech and speaking understandably—should be our primary focus as Chinese field language-learners.
Regarding the expression “Zhōngwén
(Zhōng·wén
{Central → [Chinese]} · Writing
中文)”, another thing I have noticed is that when Mandarin-speakers say “Zhōngwén
(Zhōng·wén
{Central → [Chinese]} · Writing
中文)”, they mean Mandarin speech, but when Cantonese-speakers say “Zhōngwén
(Zhōng·wén
{Central → [Chinese]} · Writing
中文)”, they mean Cantonese speech. As a Chinese person, I must reluctantly admit that with such habits, and with naming their nation
“Zhōngguó
(Zhōng·guó
Central · Nation → [China]
中国
中國)”, the central nation of the world, many Chinese people have taken quite far the tendency of imperfect humans to consider themselves the centre of the universe!
